Archive for November, 2009

Grails HTTP-based test plugins

Wednesday, November 18th, 2009

grails-logoThere are two leading frameworks for doing http-based integration tests within the Grails framework: functional-test and webtest. Both are packaged as grails plugins and accomplish the same task in a similar manner. The main library behind the scene is HtmlUnit. This is a well thought out library for abstracting web conversations, i.e get this url, check that it has a form, click the submit button. It’s basically a headless browser which even supports Javascript. HtmlUnit appears to have taken the mantle from HttpUnit as the premeir library in this small arena. There has only been one release since 2006 for HttpUnit while HtmlUnit has been very active with 11 releases in the same period.

Webtest is the more established project with its first release in 2007. Webtest is provided by Canoo as a free open source plugin to Grails. The tests are run via an Ant script that packages together the test cases and runs through each one.

Functional-test is a relatively new project with its first release in early 2009. Functional test is basically the same as webtests however instead of using the Ant-based scripts everything is based on Junit and implemented in plain old java or groovy.

We’ve chosen to proceed with using the Junit-based plugin for our HTTP integration tests. Our primary reason in deciding to use Junit is that it integrates well with our other unit-based tests which also use Junit instead of using disparate frameworks for the various types of tests. While this plugin may be newer it’s traffic on the mailing lists is growing and substantial.